2004 Calon Segur

Quite evolved Cabernet. If I were served this as coming from somewhere other than Bordeaux (eg Italy, Chile or Margaret River) I suspect I would rave about it. Very fluid and well balanced, though no longer uniquely Bordeaux. Lovely well-balanced minerally wine, but without great concentration. And a tad tart. (JR)

This classically-styled claret did not merit an outstanding rating because it lacks sufficient concentration to compete with the estate’s top vintages. However, it offers a dark ruby/plum color, nicely evolved notes of roasted herbs, sweet cherries and currants, and loamy earth, medium-weight, light to moderate tannin, and an elegant style. If it puts on weight over the next few years, it may deserve a slightly higher score. Anticipated maturity: now-2018.

Deep ruby-red. Aromas of cherry, mocha, milk chocolate and iron. Chewy and on the dry side but stuffed with flavors of cherry, plum, iron, tobacco and mocha. This has fat and sweetness for the year, along with a suggestion of herbs. Finishes with dusty tannins and moderate lift.